♪ Conscience Is Expensive · Hear the song on the Music page →
TR · P03
Conscience is expensive
Openness was expected to produce caution. It produced a race.
The second novel contains an idea that costs its own central argument everything, and I would rather readers sat with it than agreed with me about it.
The idea is this. The safeguard is the inefficiency. Every protection built into a system — the check, the pause, the exception, the human being who has to be asked — is a cost. Remove it and the system runs faster, cheaper and better. Whoever removes it first is rewarded. And the person who removes it is not a villain. They are usually right on the merits.
The book says it in a sentence that has been quoted back to me more than any other: conscience is expensive, and efficiency is not.
It then does something harder. It has openness fail. Not secrecy. Openness. The reasoning in the novel runs that transparency was expected to produce scrutiny, and it did; that scrutiny was expected to produce caution, and it did not; that what openness actually produced was competition, with thirty-nine governments racing to build on the same architecture, each one improving it by removing the deliberate flaws that had been left in on purpose.
A door left ajar, the book says, is by definition a door that does not protect.
You do not need a novel for the general shape of this. You need only ask why the safe version of a thing tends to arrive after the fast version, and who paid for the difference.
The second book also puts numbers on where it goes. It cites a cost crossover already passed, machines driving passengers through traffic in twelve cities, and a projection of one hundred million humanoid machines by 2035 in a market worth four point eight five trillion dollars within a decade. It says the trajectory mirrors the early motor car: first a curiosity, then a luxury, then a necessity without which ordinary life becomes impossible.
Those are the novel's figures, in the novel's briefing, and a reader is free to test them.
What I would ask a reader to test instead is the sentence underneath them. If the careful version is always slower than the careless one, and both are legal, and both are for sale, which one ends up in your house?
These essays sit beside the novels. Download any of our novels, free and in full.